This
article was written for and first published in
Captive Canada:
Renditions of the Peaceable Kingdom at War,
from Narratives of WWI and the Red Scare to the Mass Internment of Civilians
Issue #68 of
Press for Conversion (Spring 2016),
pp.38-39.
Press for Conversion! is the magazine of the
Coalition to Oppose the Arms Trade
(COAT).
Please subscribe, order a copy &/or donate with this
coupon,
or use the paypal link on our webpage.
If you quote from or
use this article, please cite the source above and encourage people to
subscribe. Thanks.
Here is the pdf version of this
article as it appears in Press for Conversion!
From Csarist Pogroms to Canada’s WWII
Internment Camps for Jews and Communists
By Richard Sanders, Coordinator,
Coalition to
Oppose the Arms Trade (COAT)
Blamed for strikes and protests in the 1905-1907 revolution, Russian Jews were
targeted by Czarist forces and attacked by vigilantes. Fleeing state terror and
privatised progroms, thousands sought refuge in
Canada.
Canada’s Jewish population rose from 16,000 in 1901 to 76,000 in 1911. While
2,400 Jews entered Canada per year between 1901 and 1904, the annual average
soon rose to 7,700 (1905-1908).
Most were from Russia, just as 85% of America’s 1910 Jewish population
was Russian.1
Journalist Israel Medres, who came
to Montreal from Russia in 1922,
said “a migration of unprecedented size arrived in the Quebec metropolis
following the Russian revolution of 1905.”2
They were met by an antiSemitic/antiRed hatred that typified Canada, especially
its elites. In 1907, Liberal MP, Armand Lavergne, decrying the “mongrel
population...that comes in by flocks,” told Parliament that in 1906
“Montreal [had]...a
socialist parade with the red flag of anarchy at its head, and possibly this
year, if the police do not interfere, we shall have a repetition of that
procession. In a few years the Jewish population of
Montreal
has increased from 8,000 to 40,000.”3
Arguing that only “a more desirable class of people” be allowed through
Canada’s gates, Lavergne warned that “[o]therwise we shall be strangers in our
own country and the foreigners will be the masters.”4
In the 1930s and 1940s,
Canada
refused to aid Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Europe. In 1939, the Liberal
government even deployed our Navy to expel a passenger ship because it held 900
Jewish refugees. As detailed in None is Too Many, Canadian elites were
rabidly antiSemitic, especially in Quebec where:
“Church leaders, nationalist politicians, and the social
elite united...in support of a boycott of Jewish owned businesses, ...and...bar
Canada’s door to the further admission of Jews.”5
Less known is
that beginning in 1940, Canada’s Liberals locked up 2,300 European refugees,
mostly Jews, in eight POW camps in Quebec, Ontario and New Brunswick. Having
escaped Nazi Europe, these civilians were put in British and then Canadian
internment camps, with fascists. After July 1941, these Jewish and communist
refugees remained captive, but behind the barbed wire of Canadian “refugee
camps.” Many were not freed til late 1943.
Hundreds of the antiNazi refugees held in Canada were communists. These
POWs were of prime concern to authorities. In 1941, over 45% of the 500
internees in Camp Farnham, near Montreal, were Communist supporters. Camp
authorities reported that inmates had elected “Communists or Communist
sympathizers...for most of the posts.” When indignant Reds became “assertive and
vocal,” seven of their “ring-leaders” were targeted for transfer to the prison
camp on Île Ste. Hélène (future site of Expo 67). Other inmates reacted to this
with a mass, hunger strike.6
Journalist Eric Koch, who was interned in a Quebec POW camp during WWII, said
“Communists were in the forefront of those making demands.” As a Jew who fled to
Britain from Nazi Germany, Koch said “Communists were activists and
trouble-makers” who
agitated for refugee rights from within the Canadian camps.7
References
1. American Jewish Yearbook, 1913-1914, 1914, pp.424, 428, 436.
http://www.ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1913_1914_8_Statistics.pdf
2. Israel Medres, in Through the Eyes of the Eagle: The Early
Montreal
Yiddish Press 1907-1916,
2000, p.31. Pierre Anctil (trans.)
3. Hansard, April 9, 1907, p.6155
http://parl.canadiana.ca/view/oop.debates_HOC1003_04/76?r=0&s=3
4. Ibid.., p.6156.
5. Irving Abella and Harold Troper, None Is Too Many:
Canada and the Jews of Europe,
1933-1948, 2012.
http://books.google.ca/books?id=yQfauc7aQ-UC&pg=PT8&
6. Martin Auger,
Prisoners of the Home Front: A Social Study of the German Internment Camps of
Southern Quebec,
1940-1946, 2000,
pp.77, 84.
http://books.google.ca/books?id=7NTN3u1qnUIC&
7. Eric Koch, Deemed Suspect: A
Wartime Blunder, 1980.